[ID: Eric Andre raising his hand, like in a classroom askingĀ āWhat if [they were trans]?ā end.]
[nita] munus-ra munus nita-ra ku-ku-dĆØ įµinanna za-kam
trans.Ā āto transform men into women and women to men is yours, inanna.ā from in-nin Å”a-gur-ra. enheduanna, ca. 2250 BCE (via patrexes)
ok, so I was gonna infodump in the tags, but I think this is important enough to talk about on the post itself.
Inanna was the supreme Goddess of ancient Sumer, a region of what is now known as the middle east. She was a queen who ventured into the underworld to save her husband, and came back alive. (Her story is one of the many pre-Christian stories of death and rebirth/resurrection.) She was heavily revered, more so than any male god at the time (even though she did have a male consort, as mentioned before).
Enheduanna was a priestess to Inanna. Not only was she one of the first (if not the first) priests or priestesses whose names are still known today, but she was actually one of the first authors to still have her name still preserved. Pretty much all the writing we have that was from before her time was written by anonymous scribes or chisel-workers; her writing is the oldest (or one of the oldest) with a name attached to the writer.
Itās already known that many ancient and Indigenous societies accepted trans people, butā¦seeing writing thatās pretty clearly supposed to be about trans people, written by the oldest, most ancient priestess we know of, which says that trans people are under the *direct* care and domain of the most important goddess in the society of that priestessā¦sure is something.
thanks for adding some context! hereās actually some more, because iām real fucking weak for inanna.Ā
trans people played a major part as priestesses and other staff in her cult (itās even been argued that trans people were the onlyĀ people who served as her cultic staff, though thatās generally received with some discontent). transness was considered inexplicably tied to the goddess and imparted by her in some respect, as we see from erra IV,Ā ālĆŗ kur-Äar-ra lĆŗ issini Å”a ana
Å”uplu niÅ”e iÅ”tar zikarussunu uteru ana sinniÅ”utiā, trans.Ā āthe kurÄarru and assinu, the people beneath iÅ”tar/inanna whom she has transformed from virile men into womenā.Ā
now, note, all of the english translations of erra IV iāve come across (iām mostly affording my own translations here, because people use slurs a lot when they translate sumero-akkadian and i aināt about that life) add something likeĀ āin order to strike fear into the peopleā when quoting that transliteration, but a) thereās nothing in that passage i can figure to get that meaning and b) that description is inconsistent with other descriptions of the kurÄarru and assinu (who are also called,
variably, gala, pilipili, sag-ur-sag, kalu, kuluāu, and ur-sal). inĀ āthe descent of inanna to the underworldā, we see the creation of the first of these by enki for the indisposed inanna: as you noted, inanna does indeed survive the trip, and it is solely because of her explicitly transgender priestesses.Ā
[the gala-tur and
kur-Äar-ra] flitted through the door [to the underworld] like flies. they slipped through the door pivots like phantoms. [ā¦]
[ereÅ”-ki-gal-la] asked: āwho are you? i tell you from my heart to your heart, from my body to your body ā if you are gods, i will talk with you; if you are mortals, may a destiny be decreed for you.ā they made her swear this by heaven and earth.
they were offered a river with its water ā they did not accept it. they were offered a field with its grain ā they did not accept it.
they said to her: āgive us the corpse hanging on the hook.ā
shining ereÅ”-ki-gal-la answered the gala-tur and
kur-Äar-ra:Ā āthe corpse is that of your queen.ā
they said to her:Ā āwhether it is that of our king, or whether it is that of our queen, give it to us.ā
they were given the corpse hanging on a hook. [the kur-Äar-ra] sprinkled on it the life-giving plant, and the other the life-giving water. and thus, inanna rose.
when the fuck have your faves ever, am i right?Ā
and, hell, inanna herself in aĀ Å”ir-namÅ”ub (āincantation hymnā; a hymn or poem written in voice, for the sake of performance) says this: āeĀ kaÅ”-a-ka tuÅ”
-a-[Äu-ne] / nu-nus-Äen
Å”ul giri-zal-la me-e-Äen-[na]ā, trans.Ā āto sit in the tavern, i go as a woman [or] i go as a joyful young manā.
Transphobia is a class issue. By this I mean that in a class society that is also deeply transphobic, it is impossible to talk about transphobia in a meaningful way without also talking about class. Trans people are more likely, all other things being equal, than our cis peers to fall into the most exploited and oppressed sections of the working class and the extent to which transphobia will negatively affect any given trans personās life will be mediated by their economic class. This article is not intended to be a comprehensive analysis of every aspect of this issue, but to contribute to an ongoing conversation around it and illustrate a class struggle perspective on transgender issues.
I love being a woman. A capital G Girl. A fine young lady. Itās great that I identify as a woman and am One! Isnāt it just a wonderful day when you wake up and realise āHey! Am girl!ā What an age we live in.